inSync for life Psychology
  • Home
  • Services
    • Supervision
    • Counselling >
      • General
      • Drug and Alcohol Counselling
    • Relationships, Sexuality, Intimacy
    • Mediation
    • Assessments >
      • Forensic Psychology
      • Child Development Assessment
      • Intellectual and Cognitive Assessments
    • Workshops >
      • Managing The Emotional Storm
      • Circle of Security
  • About
    • Our Team >
      • Steve >
        • Steve: Training & Development
      • Helena >
        • Helena Training & Development
      • Joshua
      • Carl
      • Mary
      • Caroline
      • James
      • Louise
      • Natasha
  • Resources
    • Downloads
    • Counselling Links
    • Forensic Psychology Links
    • Workshop Links
    • Relationship Tips
    • 5 Tips to Better Therapy
    • Sexuality Quiz
    • The Gottman Method for Healthy Relationships
    • Relationship and Sexual Health Links
  • Work with Us
    • clinical psych information
  • Contact
  • Newsletters
    • Counselling Newsletter
    • Forensic Psychology Newsletter
    • Relationships, Sexuality & Intimacy Newsletter
    • For Health Professionals
    • Previous News Items
  • Emergency Telephone contacts
  • Downloads
  • Bunbury Office
  • Wait Times
  • The Gottman Method and Helena
  • Feedback page

Entitlement and Crime: is there a link?

17/11/2016

3 Comments

 
Picture

A sense of entitlement and criminal behaviour

Assessment of risk offending behaviour - Part 1

A very common theme that arises whenever I speak of crime and the factors that might influence criminal behaviour, is
that of:
a ‘sense of entitlement’.
 
There seems to be a commonly held belief that much crime these days results from the presence of a:
‘you owe me’ attitude.
 
Which, many suggest, is frequently found in our younger generation.
 
So, is a sense of entitlement really a factor influencing criminal behaviour?
  
Before answering this question directly, it’s important to examine a few issues related to the prediction of crime...
First, the prediction of crime, or what we refer to as the assessment of risk, is not an easy or straight-forward process – humans are immensely complex beings, with many, many factors affecting our behaviour.
 
Second, the risk assessment processes or tools that we have are not 100% full-proof... There are currently two broad areas of risk assessment:
 
  1. a statistical estimate: obtained from determining the presence of historical risk factors, which generally don’t change with time. Risk is obtained from a comparison to other similar offenders
 
  1. structured professional judgement which determines the presence or absence of recognised risk factors, and then making a professional judgement of the level of risk. These risk factors are called dynamic factors, because they can and do change over time. They are also referred to as ‘criminogenic needs’ because it’s on these that counselling or treatment of the individual must focus on to reduce further offending.

Assessment of risk frequently takes into account the presence (or absence) of both the static and dynamic risk factors. For the purpose here, examining a sense of entitlement, we will look further at the dynamic risk factors, or criminogenic treatment needs.
 
So, what is a recognised dynamic risk factor:
 
Researchers, Andrews and Bonta in their fascinating book, The Psychology of Criminal Conduct (1998), suggest three determinants needed for identification of a criminogenic need (risk factor):
 
  1. The ability to distinguish criminal from non-criminal behaviour
  2. The ability to be effectively measured
  3. The ability to generate change
 
As an example of the above, here are some of the recognised and well- accepted dynamic treatment needs for general offending behaviour, as determined from extensive research and proposed by Andrews and Bonta:
 
  • Antisocial attitudes and beliefs
    • Antisocial friends
    • Antisocial behaviour
  • Problems with family or intimate relationships
  • Alcohol or other drug problems
  • Employment problems
  • No involvement in healthy recreational/leisure activities
 
Further lists of criminogenic treatment needs (risk factors), have been found for more specific types of offending, including violence, sexual, spousal assault, and stalking.
 
But, at this stage, a ‘sense of entitlement’ does not make any of the lists determining static or dynamic risk factors.

However...
... research in 2011, has shown some promise: in a paper entitled: An examination of a sense of entitlement in violent men: Violence towards others and the self, Dr Sofia Fisher found that a sense of entitlement differentiated between violent offenders (who reported higher levels of entitlement) and non-violent offenders.
This difference however, was only found in those who committed violence offences, NOT non-violence offences.
 
But...in a later study in 2013, Narcissism and Empathy in Young Offenders and Non-Offenders, the researchers found that feelings of entitlement, a strong factor found in
Narcissism, together with the resulting lack of empathy, is likely to have accounted for a greater likelihood of general criminal behaviour.
 
So, the bottom line?
…it does seem from this research, that a sense of entitlement may indeed be found to be a criminogenic risk factor – at this stage, it seems to meet the first two of the three criteria suggested by Andrews and Bonta.
 
But, the problem is, it does not yet meet the third factor, that of ‘the ability to change’.
You see, it is not yet known whether an inflated sense of entitlement, or the self-belief of deserving more than others, can be altered either over time, or through appropriate intervention. If it is a reflection of a true personality disorder, then chances are, it cannot be changed…managed yes…but changed, no.
As the saying goes...the jury is still out on this one...

We welcome feedback and your comments...
Steve Jobson
DOWNLOAD PDF
3 Comments
uk custom essays link
30/9/2018 05:18:36 pm

Crime is a very serious thing. It can be in a physical way or in a non-violent way. People have different motives for the crimes they commit, but it all starts within the mind. Crime is a psychological battle. When we feel that we do not have everything or we want something from someone else, this can lead to someone taking action, but in an illegal way. Like most things we do in our lives, crime always starts within and manifests its way into action.

Reply
Alfred link
19/4/2023 12:44:34 pm

You may not control every one of the occasions that happen to you, however you can choose not to be decreased by them.

Reply
Telkom University link
28/5/2024 11:35:40 am

How does entitlement relate to criminal behavior, and what insights does forensic psychology offer into understanding this connection? Visit us <a href="https://journals.telkomuniversity.ac.id/">Telkom University</a>

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    May 2018
    November 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016

    Topics & Authors

    All
    Ciara Togher
    Crime
    Criminogenic
    Firesetting
    Paths
    Steve Jobson

    RSS Feed

  At inSync for life, we acknowledge the Traditional Custodians of the land on which we work and live.
We recognise their continuing connection to land, water and community, and we pay respect to Elders past, present and emerging
privacy policy
terms and conditions
copyright statement
Copyright © inSync for life 2024
  • Home
  • Services
    • Supervision
    • Counselling >
      • General
      • Drug and Alcohol Counselling
    • Relationships, Sexuality, Intimacy
    • Mediation
    • Assessments >
      • Forensic Psychology
      • Child Development Assessment
      • Intellectual and Cognitive Assessments
    • Workshops >
      • Managing The Emotional Storm
      • Circle of Security
  • About
    • Our Team >
      • Steve >
        • Steve: Training & Development
      • Helena >
        • Helena Training & Development
      • Joshua
      • Carl
      • Mary
      • Caroline
      • James
      • Louise
      • Natasha
  • Resources
    • Downloads
    • Counselling Links
    • Forensic Psychology Links
    • Workshop Links
    • Relationship Tips
    • 5 Tips to Better Therapy
    • Sexuality Quiz
    • The Gottman Method for Healthy Relationships
    • Relationship and Sexual Health Links
  • Work with Us
    • clinical psych information
  • Contact
  • Newsletters
    • Counselling Newsletter
    • Forensic Psychology Newsletter
    • Relationships, Sexuality & Intimacy Newsletter
    • For Health Professionals
    • Previous News Items
  • Emergency Telephone contacts
  • Downloads
  • Bunbury Office
  • Wait Times
  • The Gottman Method and Helena
  • Feedback page